Sanctuary being torn down. We need your help!!! - click here for details
You can also visit TheSanctuaryTaiwan.org - click here to go to their contact page

[Conscript] Conscription of US cit for ROC military service

Forum rules
While the moderators are happy to help point people in the right direction for legal assistance and to attempt to keep these forums civil and tidy, please bear in mind that an Internet forum is not the place for providing or receiving legal advice or for the creation of any attorney-client privileges or obligations. Also keep in mind that Forumosa and the moderators cannot conduct comprehensive reviews of all laws or legal concepts referenced or discussed within these forums – laws and regulations are updated and amended, interpretations do change, and sometimes the legal landscape can change very fast. Forumosa provides these legal forums for general informational purposes only. By using these legal forums, you agree that the information does not constitute legal or other professional advice and no attorney-client or other relationship is created between you and any other posters on these forums. DO NOT CONSIDER THE FORUMS TO BE A SUBSTITUTE FOR OBTAINING LEGAL ADVICE FROM A QUALIFIED LICENSED ATTORNEY.

Conscription of US citizen for ROC military service

Postby JGeer » 02 Jul 2002, 07:26

So our brainwash specialists are employing very effective methods of indoctrination for weakening their wills and for gaining converts like you?

Every time you don't agree with us, you'll hear that lovely song ringing in your ears. [img]images/smiles/icon_biggrin.gif[/img]
JGeer
 



Conscription of US citizen for ROC military service

Postby Lord Lucan » 03 Jul 2002, 22:06

<blockquote><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, Geneva">quote:</font><hr>Originally posted by sandman:
<strong>five hours and 15 minutes during a trip to Mull.
</strong><hr></blockquote>

I am sure the five hour trip to Mull was worth it. I would imagine Mull of Kintyre was not sung at all either during the trip for hours on end. God how I have learnt to hate that song. "Mists rolling in" "Sea of desire" I'll give you mist you annoying little scouse
Forumosan avatar
Lord Lucan
Almost a God (jīhū shì shén)
Almost a God (jīhū shì shén)
 
Posts: 6876
Joined: 18 Nov 1999, 17:01
Location: Taipei
4 Recommends(s)
4 Recognized(s)



Conscription of US citizen for ROC military service

Postby BAH » 04 Jul 2002, 13:25

Richard,

An interesting idea. I am a dual citizen of conscription age, but I will decline the offer to volunteer to be drafted.

I had a professor (American of German descent) who, while studying in Taiwan during the 70s, was drafted. He wasn't a dual citizen or anything. He dutifully showed up after receiving the draft notice, but was immediately told to go home.
Forumosan avatar
BAH
Chair-throwing Legislator (rēng yǐzi de lìfǎ wěiyuán)
Chair-throwing Legislator (rēng yǐzi de lìfǎ wěiyuán)
 
Posts: 306
Joined: 24 Oct 2001, 16:01
Location: Shanghai
1 Recommends(s)
1 Recognized(s)



Conscription of US citizen for ROC military service

Postby JGeer » 04 Jul 2002, 23:29

Back then, such a case was certainly an exception to the norm. Today, those numbers are bigger and proper measures must be established.
JGeer
 



Conscription of US citizen for ROC military service

Postby Poagao » 05 Jul 2002, 02:17

That case, of an American of German decent studying in Taiwan being "drafted", was almost certainly an administrative error. I doubt there are that many more such cases these days than there were then, i.e. an administrative error causing an incorrect draft notice to be issued.
Forumosan avatar
Poagao
Thinking of Having Kids (xiǎng yào shēng xiǎo hái)
Thinking of Having Kids (xiǎng yào shēng xiǎo hái)
 
Posts: 3982
Joined: 16 Jul 2001, 16:01
5 Recommends(s)
71 Recognized(s)



Conscription of US citizen for ROC military service

Postby JGeer » 06 Jul 2002, 00:56

The pool of permanent residents and dual citizens is probably far larger today than 25 years ago. In Taiwan there are about 5,000 US citizens with ARC and there are perhaps as many as 50,000 US-ROC dual citizens.
JGeer
 



Conscription of US citizen for ROC military service

Postby aceman » 21 Jul 2002, 11:28

I don't get whats the big deal...as long as you leave every 4 months, couldn't a dual citizen get off of the draft?
aceman
High School Triad Member (gāozhōng liúmáng)
High School Triad Member (gāozhōng liúmáng)
 
Posts: 513
Joined: 09 Jul 2002, 16:01
Location: California/Taipei



Conscription of US citizen for ROC military service

Postby JGeer » 27 Jul 2002, 04:19

No. It is a changing policy, and there are other dual nationality issues like a 1946 Treaty for US citizens in the ROC. The ROC conscription system is broken for many reasons including Laws of War. What is the exact POW status of dual US citizens in the ROC military?

To the PLA, all ROC soldiers are just rebels of their internal affairs, and they will not likely even recognize their standing as POWs like the USA does for "rebels" on Taiwan under the Geneva Conventions. The situation for US citizens is sticky because of the ICC and the more or less controversial terrorist "detainee status" in lieu of the POW status. For West Berlin, there was no question of US citizens possibly under the Geneva Convention.
JGeer
 



What a tough issue!

Postby DevilDuke » 18 Aug 2002, 18:45

All I can say is this is a really messy issue, therefore I'm going to relate to this but make a separate point. I think there's a point needed to be made here where Taiwanese and Non-Taiwanese interested in the issue forget the whys and hows. First why? Why does Taiwan need conscription? Well even if Taiwan wasn't ruled by the KMT, there still would be conscription because the main and probably only enemy Taiwan has is China and compare the full/part time military of 6 million to 100 million. Taiwanese citizens are also not known to be fanatics of nationlistic pride, therefore without conscription there wouldn't even be a talk today, right here on this board or anywhere about pro-independance. You might as well give up with a fight and recognize yourself as part of the PRC. Which leads to another issue I might state:

Imigration out of Taiwan, certainly if Taiwan indeed went through a process of initiation into officially becoming part of the PRC, or uniting, many, mainly rich and middle-class would immigrate out of the country to predominantly U.S. and Canada. Taiwanese-Americans and Chinese-Americans do have a difference, the main being almost all if not all Taiwanese-Americans have went back and visited "home".

The second issue is "how", look face it, your fortunate enough to be born in a democratic society as if you were in China and lashing out at the country for drafting you, after you've dodged to another, they'd execute you for that. The how here is how to set up a non-draft system in which male and female would seek the military as a profession out of own will and only approve a draft in the situation of war. The answer if not likely, but only possible if Taiwan has full international recognition and support of being a independant COUNTRY.
DevilDuke
 



Postby Eric W. Lier » 14 Jul 2003, 20:03

If an US court finds against Taiwan in the proposed suit, what would be the remedies available to the plaintiff and how would they be enforced ?

Here is one possible remedy. Have the plaintiff volunteer for US military service instead. The US military is the only force willing and capable of defending Taiwan. Serving in the US military as a Taiwanese American is a much more effective way of ensuring the defense of Taiwan. When the war for Taiwan takes place, Chinese speaking people trained in the ways of modern warfare will be an invaluable asset in either army.
Image
Eric W. Lier
Night Market Cop (yè shì tiáo zi)
Night Market Cop (yè shì tiáo zi)
 
Posts: 804
Joined: 19 May 2003, 12:49
Location: Taiwan



FRIENDLY REMINDER
   Please remember that Forumosa is not responsible for the content that appears on the other side of links that Forumosans post on our forums. As a discussion website, we encourage open and frank debate. We have learned that the most effective way to address questionable claims or accusations on Forumosa is by engaging in a sincere and constructive conversation. To make this website work, we must all feel safe in expressing our opinions, this also means backing up any claims with hard facts, including links to other websites.
   Please also remember that one should not believe everything one reads on the Internet, particularly from websites whose content cannot be easily verified or substantiated. Use your common sense and do not hesitate to ask for proof.
PreviousNext




Proceed to Military Conscription



Who is online

Forumosans browsing this forum: No Forumosans and 1 visitor

I have spent my days stringing and unstringing my instrument, while the song I came to sing remains unsung -- TAGORE