Click here to go to our new forums at
If you are a Forumosan Regular, when you log in for the FIRST TIME, you must RESET your password by using the Password Recovery system.

Usernames on the new forums must not contain any SPACES and must end with LETTER or a NUMBER; if yours does, you will be prompted to change your Username
Contact us at admin(at)forumosa(dot)com or @forumosa on Twitter or on our Facebook Page if you have any questions or problems logging back in

Theism vs. Atheism: Civil Discussion

Re: Theism vs. Atheism: Civil Discussion

Postby Tempo Gain » 06 Mar 2011, 19:59

Mucha Man wrote:
The :lol: was there not to mock you but as a good-natured poke. Come on man, you think people who believe in an unproven god are wrong yet you feel not the slightest need to defend your beliefs. That's funny and I certainly thought you would see the irony and not be offended.

Really, the following statement bothers me a lot more, I don't think the poke would have bothered me otherwise:

Mucha Man wrote:
If you say that the meaning if purely in your head and purely a product of evolution and has no meaning outside that, then I say you are not being honest.

That is what I am saying, and I am being honest.

Going back to the first statement, there's nothing for me to defend. We're here, that is clear. We can feel love, and enjoy the many things you listed above, and feel pain etc of course. I can't imagine you would disagree with any of that. If someone wants to make some claim beyond that, then defending it is their job :idunno:

Mucha Man wrote:
zyzzx wrote:Ok, I'm a little behind in the discussion, but this line of reasoning comes across as just a little arrogant. What in the world does a belief in god have to do with understanding love, or one's ability to find meaning in life? Who are you (or theists in general) to tell me what brings meaning to my life? Nobody knows what another person feels, or what life means to them. If anything, you are confirming that religion is more of a crutch to those searching for meaning - oh, my life has meaning because god made me.
Personally, I don't feel that I have any particular "specialness", other than the fact that I am a unique individual - both physically/genetically and in the sum of my experiences. How else would my existence be "special"? And why is feeling like it is some requirement for living a happy meaningful life?
I certainly believe that there are things that we don't or can't yet understand, but I think that we will understand them someday. We are still learning so many things about ourselves and the universe, things that would have been completely inexplicable or unknowable 100 or 200 years ago. Just because science can't explain something now doesn't mean that it never will. And I base that not on a 'belief' in science, but on an extrapolation of the evidence.

No arrogance in my post, especially considering I am not a theist. I am asking people to consider that we all believe ourselves special (or experience ourselves as special), and yes, you do too, and what does this mean if we truly adhere to a scientific explanation of our existence? I contend that we can't go around in our daily life believing we are merely a random collection of atoms affected by the processes of evolution. We just can't. We go around living and loving as if there is some higher or deeper meaning to our feelings and actions. Else why do them?

So my question, and it's as much to myself as anyone, is what does this mean? In my opinion, religious people tackle this question of value and meaning, whereas most atheists do not. I contend that atheism allows us to act as meaning somnambulists, walking through life with massive contradictions going on inside between what we believe explains ourselves, and what we truly experience about ourselves.

I agree with zyzzx here. Lest anyone misunderstand, I don't see myself as any more special than anyone else. However, nothing could be more special to me than my existence and everything that goes with it. For a start, the odds for my life even to happen were infinitesimal. Personally, I think the best measure of respect for it is to enjoy it, morally of course. It is what it is. Anything beyond that is speculation. That there is no higher or deeper meaning doesn't bother me. I don't see the need to ask such questions, but respect that you do.

Mucha Man wrote:First off, consider the contempt we may have for people who believe in God. Where does this come from? Consider that if we are all truly only a product of evolutionary forces then the capacity to believe in the supernatural is as much a part of our makeup as a capacity to love and to experience aesthetic pleasure. Now as we know, training in art improves ones capacity to appreciate art and derive pleasure from it, and by all accounts, religious training has the effect of making one more attune to spiritual experience.

So why have contempt for the person who pursues religion and not the person who pursues art? If both are literally in our own minds, they are both equally deserving of dismissal or acceptance. And yet, almost all the atheists on this thread have pointed to art, music, etc, as important values in their lives. News flash. Art is an abstraction. There is no such thing as art.

I don't have such contempt, personally.

There is also no such thing as friendship, no such thing as love, no such thing as self-respect and dignity, at least in the concrete, as we demand a theist God must exist in the concrete (ie provable by direct observation). Yet these are "things" most people hold as truly existing and worth pursuing. Where is the reality in these "things", in these values, and where is the value in these values for those with a purely rational-scientific view of existence?

I don't think your comparison between such feelings and a theist God is an apt one. My friendships and love, for example, exist; I say that with the same level of confidence that I say the earth exists. One can not say that a God exists with the same confidence, in my opinion. I do understand that many people say the feeling that God exists is as strong as human love or friendship. However, I'm not saying that there is some entity of "love" or "friendship" except as it exists as feelings between people, in the way people say God is a distinct entity. I'll also note that feelings of love and friendship are nearly universal, am I right in saying people lacking them would be classified as psychopathic? While many report the feeling of an existence of God, it's nowhere near as universal of a feeling. I don't mean for any of this to deny the validity of those feelings on a personal level for those who have them. By the way, our mammalian relatives also are not strangers to feelings of love or friendship either.

"Being alive is the meaning." -- Joseph Campbell

"Well I don't guess it has to be, but that's the way we like it." -- Roger Waters

There's only one thing left for me to do momma I gotta ding a ding dang my dang a long ling long
User avatar
Tempo Gain
Maitreya Buddha (Mílèfó)
Posts: 12859
Joined: 16 Jul 2004, 22:41
Location: Taipei

Re: Theism vs. Atheism: Civil Discussion

Postby Got To Be Kidding » 06 Mar 2011, 20:11

Tempo Gain wrote:That's not true. My friendships and love exist, the same way the earth exists. One can not say that God exists with the same confidence, in my opinion.

If I die, and then wake up seeing my latest score in a game of 'Virtual Life'...

I'll be upset.

Liberalism - politics for those who can't do math.
User avatar
Got To Be Kidding
Fried Chicken-Parts Vendor (yán sū jī xiǎofàn)
Fried Chicken-Parts Vendor (yán sū jī xiǎofàn)
Posts: 994
Joined: 20 Jan 2011, 12:18
Location: Neihu, Taipei

Re: Theism vs. Atheism: Civil Discussion

Postby dashgalaxy86 » 06 Mar 2011, 21:10

Yeah, I've never seen so much arguing among atheists in my life. It was absurd. Not really what I envisioned when I started this thread. ah well.
Chair-throwing Legislator (rēng yǐzi de lìfǎ wěiyuán)
Chair-throwing Legislator (rēng yǐzi de lìfǎ wěiyuán)
Posts: 304
Joined: 27 Sep 2007, 15:01

   Please remember that Forumosa is not responsible for the content that appears on the other side of links that Forumosans post on our forums. As a discussion website, we encourage open and frank debate. We have learned that the most effective way to address questionable claims or accusations on Forumosa is by engaging in a sincere and constructive conversation. To make this website work, we must all feel safe in expressing our opinions, this also means backing up any claims with hard facts, including links to other websites.
   Please also remember that one should not believe everything one reads on the Internet, particularly from websites whose content cannot be easily verified or substantiated. Use your common sense and do not hesitate to ask for proof.

Return to Religion & Spirituality

Who is online

Forumosans browsing this forum: No Forumosans and 3 guests