Click here to go to our new forums at
If you are a Forumosan Regular, when you log in for the FIRST TIME, you must RESET your password by using the Password Recovery system.

Usernames on the new forums must not contain any SPACES and must end with LETTER or a NUMBER; if yours does, you will be prompted to change your Username
Contact us at admin(at)forumosa(dot)com or @forumosa on Twitter or on our Facebook Page if you have any questions or problems logging back in

Third gender

A forum for discussing gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender-related issues, both specific to Taiwan and in general. This forum welcomes people of all sexual orientations to participate and share their opinions and experiences in a mature and safe environment.

Moderator: John

Re: Third gender

Postby 914 » 21 Mar 2009, 01:51

I didn't realize this was happening in Taiwan schools. I didn't think parents would be so understanding with their kids' gender identification in such a sex-biased society. But these parents are also from our generation so they're more educated and open-minded. Could it be?

I find this topic fascinating.

By the way, Battery9, your friends are cute. I'd always had a thing for tomboys. Odd. Went through a phase when I was much younger where I dressed (attempted to) as a tomboy.
Messages are sent from my iPad so if you find any errors, you may keep them. Myspacebarhasissues.
User avatar
Lost Winning Lotto Ticket (zhòngjiǎng cǎiquàn nòngdiū le)
Lost Winning Lotto Ticket (zhòngjiǎng cǎiquàn nòngdiū le)
Posts: 2853
Joined: 01 Jun 2004, 16:11
Location: YVR to SFO to TPE; Now in semi-retirement in Sky Mother

Re: Third gender

Postby Chuanzao El Ale Destroyer » 21 Mar 2009, 11:50

914 wrote:I didn't realize this was happening in Taiwan schools. I didn't think parents would be so understanding with their kids' gender identification in such a sex-biased society. But these parents are also from our generation so they're more educated and open-minded. Could it be?

I find this topic fascinating.

I do too.
Battery9. he/she is about ten. She/he isn't a tomboy. He/she looks like a girl and has long hair and non-tomboyish clothing, yet my boss told me that the parents told him student is indeed a biological boy and that I am to refer to suudent as "he". I don't want to ask more questions because I just want to go on teaching without issue. But Taiwan culture is very interesting.

The reason I speculated about ambiguos genitalia is because I recently watched this documentary:
part one:
part two: ... re=related
part three: ... re=related

It was originally on the learning channel.

I am now a supporter of rights for gender ambiguous individuals. I never gave much thought to it before. I am happy that it seems that Asia is further along on this topic than the west.
User avatar
Chuanzao El Ale Destroyer
Fried Chicken-Parts Vendor (yán sū jī xiǎofàn)
Fried Chicken-Parts Vendor (yán sū jī xiǎofàn)
Posts: 979
Joined: 27 Jan 2008, 12:40

Re: Third gender

Postby european » 23 Mar 2009, 04:01

I don't think the 'third gender' thing is at all common here compared to say Thailand or the Philippines for that matter.

And the 'third gender' I am talking about is (the western term being) trans gender - male to female.
There are tomboys about and camp looking men on almost every street, but third sex?
I've seen a handful over the years (one of which groped me in a street asking me to go back to her apartment).

Bring the subject up with students over the age of twelve (in every case for me, they brought it up) and you'll be met with laughter and cries of 'renyao' which in case you don't know, means people monster.
That is usually met with some myopic comments about the 'renyao' being gay.

Which is a sharp contrast to Thailand - where thankfully they are certainly tolerated (a little less so by some ethnic Chinese there) and viewed as a third sex.
Newspaper Copyeditor (bàoshè biānjí)
Newspaper Copyeditor (bàoshè biānjí)
Posts: 432
Joined: 23 Jan 2003, 09:06

Re: Third gender

Postby economy ah » 25 Mar 2009, 12:03

How sweet. It is the slightly older ones that you should worry about, with the large adams apples who threaten all sorts of unpleasant things should you look at them critically in their natural habitat. There are many in Malaysia and Singapore as well, and most look quite beautiful from a few feet away.
economy ah
Mastered ordering "beer" in Chinese (jīngtōng le yòng Guóyǔ shuō "píjiǔ")
Mastered ordering "beer" in Chinese (jīngtōng le yòng Guóyǔ shuō "píjiǔ")
Posts: 105
Joined: 04 May 2008, 05:49

Re: Third gender

Postby Liz_Taipei » 30 Mar 2009, 19:14

This story reminds me of something I heard years ago and that always intrigued me.

An expat friend of mine was friends with this very tomboy looking Taiwanese 'female', who was legally a woman: name, voice, ID card. But she often said she would rather have been a man, she had 'manly' interests and hobbies, she could easily have passed for a man if it were not for the voice, etc. I later learned that, let me quote: "when her mom was changing her nappy, she didn't know if that baby was a boy or a girl"... I didn't dare to ask more questions or, God forbids, for a quick look at the object of confusion...

That woman must now be about 40-42 years old, and was born in the South of Taiwan, so we can all guess the state of hospital/medical technology/mentality at that time. She wasn't dating anyone nor seemed to have any 'carnal' inclination towards either men or women.

I am amazed to read about Chuanzao's student case! I wonder why parents wouldn't want their kid to be operated at birth.
Memorized My Password (gāng jìhǎo zìjǐ de mìmǎ)
Posts: 55
Joined: 09 May 2004, 19:40
Location: Taipei

Re: Third gender

Postby Battery9 » 30 Mar 2009, 20:14

the problem is that you can't choose the gender so early. Many kids get operated on early..but later the child wants to be the opposite sex. Like, you may cut off the penis, but then the girl feels that there is something wrong with her, in the wrong body etc.

I watched an Oprah episode about parents being fine with their kids that want to be the opposite sex. It is so intriguing. There is a big difference between a tomboy girl who wants to climb trees and be boyish, and a girl who screams and becomes depressed when she has to wear a dress.
Presidential Advisor (zǒng tǒng gù wèn)
Presidential Advisor (zǒng tǒng gù wèn)
Posts: 3107
Joined: 22 Nov 2004, 18:19
Location: Xindian County

   Please remember that Forumosa is not responsible for the content that appears on the other side of links that Forumosans post on our forums. As a discussion website, we encourage open and frank debate. We have learned that the most effective way to address questionable claims or accusations on Forumosa is by engaging in a sincere and constructive conversation. To make this website work, we must all feel safe in expressing our opinions, this also means backing up any claims with hard facts, including links to other websites.
   Please also remember that one should not believe everything one reads on the Internet, particularly from websites whose content cannot be easily verified or substantiated. Use your common sense and do not hesitate to ask for proof.

Return to LGBT Forum

Who is online

Forumosans browsing this forum: No Forumosans and 2 guests