Quick english grammar sanity check?

Moderator: Tempo Gain

Quick english grammar sanity check?

Postby pqkdzrwt » 10 Sep 2011, 11:09

Saw this on a Taiwanese english test, what is the correct answer?

The course was divided into three sessions, __ was taught by a different instructor.

1) each of them
2) it 
3) which
4) each of which


How would you answer? Every single student answered 1 even though to me that doesn't sound quite right.
Never wrestle with a pig—you get dirty and the pig likes it
pqkdzrwt
Scooter Commuter (qí jī chē shàng xià bān)
Scooter Commuter (qí jī chē shàng xià bān)
 
Posts: 697
ORIGINAL POSTER
Joined: 09 Apr 2010, 01:01
Location: 臺灣台中
4 Recommends(s)
18 Recognized(s)

6000

Re: Quick english grammar sanity check?

Postby Lili » 10 Sep 2011, 11:14

It should be a semi-colon if you use "each of them", not a comma.

3 is the correct answer. But the sentence is wrong because I assume the test maker wanted to state that each session was taught by a different teacher. However, when one uses choice 3 all you are saying is that the class is taught by a different teacher than another class and btw, there are three sessions in this class.

It should be "The course was divided into three sessions; each of which was taught by a different instructor."
I believe...
"I wanted to be puzzled and charmed, to experience the endless, beguiling variety of a continent where you can board a train and an hour later be somewhere where the inhabitants speak a different language, eat different foods, work different hours, live lives that are at once so different and yet so oddly similar. I wanted to be a tourist," Bill Bryson.
"...But I ended up in Taiwan," Lili.

Never underestimate how much assistance,
how much satisfaction,
how much comfort,
how much soul and transcendence there might be
in a cold bottle of beer.
-Tom Robbins
Forumosan avatar
Lili
Eldest Grandchild (zhǎngsūn)
Eldest Grandchild (zhǎngsūn)
 
Posts: 1199
Joined: 22 Jan 2011, 14:13
Location: Taipei
21 Recommends(s)
23 Recognized(s)

6000

Re: Quick english grammar sanity check?

Postby Funk500 » 10 Sep 2011, 11:16

Lili wrote:It should be a semi-colon if you use "each of them", not a comma.

3 is the correct answer. But the sentence is wrong.

It should be "The course was divided into three sessions; each of which was taught by a different instructor."
I believe...

surely you mean 4
Forumosan avatar
Funk500
Generalissimo (dàyuánshuài)
Generalissimo (dàyuánshuài)
 
Posts: 4408
Joined: 01 Nov 2004, 18:28
19 Recommends(s)
9 Recognized(s)

6000

Re: Quick english grammar sanity check?

Postby Nuit » 10 Sep 2011, 11:27

got no problem with 4, and a comma. But then I don't teach grammar and thinking about it, I rarely use semi-colons myself. Happy to be put right.
It's raining again here. I'm rising up like a beautiful bubble to the surface.

A wicked wind whips up the hill, a handful of hopeful words.
I was what you would call seriously strung out.
Forumosan avatar
Nuit
Mando-pop Singer (Guóyǔ liúxíng gēshǒu)
Mando-pop Singer (Guóyǔ liúxíng gēshǒu)
 
Posts: 2383
Joined: 25 Jan 2008, 23:43
Location: 東部
73 Recommends(s)
89 Recognized(s)

6000

Re: Quick english grammar sanity check?

Postby pqkdzrwt » 10 Sep 2011, 11:35

All of the students chose answer 1. I had thought the correct answer was 4, but I wanted to check first to make sure I wasn't going crazy.
Never wrestle with a pig—you get dirty and the pig likes it
pqkdzrwt
Scooter Commuter (qí jī chē shàng xià bān)
Scooter Commuter (qí jī chē shàng xià bān)
 
Posts: 697
ORIGINAL POSTER
Joined: 09 Apr 2010, 01:01
Location: 臺灣台中
4 Recommends(s)
18 Recognized(s)

6000

Re: Quick english grammar sanity check?

Postby Hartzell » 10 Sep 2011, 11:47

It could be argued that the Chinese language is without the concept of "which."

Hence, that is a difficult point for very many Chinese speaking students.

It is not surprising to me that most students in Taiwan would tend to pick answer 1.
Richard W. Hartzell
contact me by email at rwh.midway@gmail.com
Neihu District, Taipei (114)
Forumosan avatar
Hartzell
Mando-pop Singer (Guóyǔ liúxíng gēshǒu)
Mando-pop Singer (Guóyǔ liúxíng gēshǒu)
 
Posts: 2342
Joined: 31 Oct 2000, 17:01
Location: Nei Hu District, Taipei, Taiwan
19 Recognized(s)

6000

Re: Quick english grammar sanity check?

Postby Abacus » 10 Sep 2011, 12:43

my grammar is awful. But I would just simplify it to: ...sessions and each was... I also have no idea what punctuation to use in the previous sentence.

Of course I've butchered the American language since I was born. :discodance:

imo this is a case of the native grammar nazi's trying to police the local grammar nazi's and further derailing the students from actually gaining useful comprehension of the language. I would be more interested in knowing if the students could identify which word each replaces.
Abacus
Presidential Advisor (zǒng tǒng gù wèn)
Presidential Advisor (zǒng tǒng gù wèn)
 
Posts: 3268
Joined: 20 Aug 2009, 08:14
Location: Kaohsiung
104 Recommends(s)
113 Recognized(s)

6000

Re: Quick english grammar sanity check?

Postby merge » 10 Sep 2011, 12:51

Answer 4, no semicolon needed.
Your pal.

This post was recommended by tomthorne (13 Sep 2011, 13:47)
Rating: 5.88%
merge
Fried Chicken-Parts Vendor (yán sū jī xiǎofàn)
Fried Chicken-Parts Vendor (yán sū jī xiǎofàn)
 
Posts: 920
Joined: 11 May 2004, 09:12
Location: Smack dab in the middle
20 Recommends(s)
8 Recognized(s)

6000

Re: Quick english grammar sanity check?

Postby Petrichor » 10 Sep 2011, 13:42

Answer 1 sounds wrong because it's a new piece of information, so needs a semi-colon or full stop to separate it from the previous sentence.
Answer 2 and 3 are wrong because 'it' and 'which' are singular pronouns and the object referred to in the first part of the sentence is plural (sessions) so there is disagreement.
Answer 4 is correct. It's a non-defining relative clause. The 'each of which' refers back to the preceding clause but doesn't define it, just gives more detail.
Use what talents you possess: The woods would be very silent if no birds sang there except those that sang best.

http://talesfromthebeautifulisle.blogspot.com/
Forumosan avatar
Petrichor
Bird Walker (liù niǎo de rén)
 
Posts: 1429
Joined: 22 Dec 2008, 04:30
Location: Muzha
82 Recommends(s)
84 Recognized(s)

6000

Re: Quick english grammar sanity check?

Postby pqkdzrwt » 10 Sep 2011, 13:43

Abacus wrote:imo this is a case of the native grammar nazi's trying to police the local grammar nazi's and further derailing the students from actually gaining useful comprehension of the language. I would be more interested in knowing if the students could identify which word each replaces.


I agree that a significant number of native english speakers could probably not answer this question correctly but it distracts from the main point.


Lets assume for the sake of the discussion this is an advanced/high level test for native chinese speakers trying to perfect their English. (: None of us would want to deny a Tawanese person a chance to polish / perfect their english to a native english level.
Never wrestle with a pig—you get dirty and the pig likes it
pqkdzrwt
Scooter Commuter (qí jī chē shàng xià bān)
Scooter Commuter (qí jī chē shàng xià bān)
 
Posts: 697
ORIGINAL POSTER
Joined: 09 Apr 2010, 01:01
Location: 臺灣台中
4 Recommends(s)
18 Recognized(s)

6000

Next




 

Return to Grammar, Usage and Pronunciation



Who is online

Forumosans browsing this forum: No Forumosans and 0 visitors

The fear of death follows from the fear of life. A man who lives fully is prepared to die at any time -- MARK TWAIN